I hate to dislike movies. As someone who tries to catch at least 3 a week (more if I can), I usually wind up accepting the vast majority of entertinment thrown at me. I can meet it where it is and enjoy it for what it is. When i don’t like a movie, like really don’t like it, Itry to go online and read the opinions of Variety, The Hollyowod Reporter, and Roger Ebert for some insight.
Maybe there was something I missed, ya know? Sometimes, however, after reading these reviews as well as a message board over at The Movie Blog, I just accept that I didn’t like the film; and that’s okay. I don’t have to. Those who do, who “got it” and enjoyed it, I am very happy for, but I can accept taht some movies I just hate. Open Water happens to be one of them.
Now, first and foremost, I wish those who had success through the film, the director and actors and crew, the very best. This was an indy film to the max–under 150k budget, all produced, coordinated, and completed by a husband-and-wife duo, out-of-pocket. They gambled on a dream, and it paid off. I am unabashedly happy for their success. They certainly earned it for the risk they took in this production. The actors likewise took a risk, and I applaud their efforts.
That being said, I felt the directing in this film was not only uninteresting and flat, but I abhorred the performances by the leads, felt awkward by the gratuitous nudity; and felt an overall sense of nihilistic depression by the movie’s end–not only because the ending is so uneventful and poorly played, but because the characters were so hollow and foolish that I could not but help but think, “We humans are doomed.” In fact, the best directed and acted part of the movie is the segment involving a a man who forgot his scuba mask and the screw’s miscount as a result. Other than that, the movie had very little I enjoyed or could even tolerate. I really didn’t believe the actors for a moment, and the shot selection, less a solid 20 shots, was horrendous–like a high school student film by someone uninterested in the movies.
I mean, it really takes alot for me to just dislike a movie start-to-finish. Sometimes it’s a theme, an exploitative sequence, or a bad performance. Sometimes I just think it’s all a mess. Open Water seems to be the victim of all or any of these personal pet peeves of mine, and for that, I give it a 1


